EAA Sport Aviation Magazine, September 2023, Incursion and Deviations

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
Has anyone read the EAA Sport Aviation Magazine, September 2023, Incursion and Deviations?

I'm happy that Steve Krog has put in print this continuous growing problem of lack of situational awareness while operating an aircraft.

I've added a link to a previous thread of my comments on the growing culture of perpetual lack of personal situational awareness in aviation and all other parts of life.

Wayne

And with those vision limitations, one must remain extra vigilant with situational awareness in relation with nearby terrain and aircraft. This goes back to the lack of situational awareness I started this discussion with.

The past year on two separate occasions, I was invited to fly X-country with two different young (twenty-something year old) pilots. Each flight was months apart. They were building time to obtain their CFI.

Before the flight started, I asked where are we flying to, what is the route, what is the weather, what alternate airports are on the route, and are there any NOTAMS active? On both instances, each young pilot looked at me with blank stares. Then each one told me verbatim, "Man you're old school. The GPS will tell them which direction to fly, if "I" need to know the weather, my phone will tell me, if I need an alternate, my GPS will tell me." Neither one admitted checking for NOTAMs. I need to add that neither pilot had flown the route nor land at the airport they were planning to fly to before. I said to them, "Let's pull out a PAPER sectional and review the route together. Reviewed the airports including fuel availability we were flying to and the alternates, review all the frequencies we shall be using on AirNav.com. Checked weather and NOTAMs. On one flight, we found out that the airport we were flying to had several taxiways closed for construction. For the separate flight, we found out the alternate airport chosen was closed for runway resurfacing.

What got me was both pilots asked me, "Do you always waste your time doing this planning before every flight? I said, "Yes always since day one when I started to fly. And it is NEVER waited time" Again each reply was almost verbatim. "If I need any of this information, I will do this during the flight there. Otherwise I deal with the changes when it happens. That's what GPS and phones are for." I told them in performing this exercise before every flight, you will lay down the foundation for situational awareness within your brain. They have become familiar with everything before entering the cockpit. Then their reply was, "I don't do this when I get into my car. I don't know the route nor my location I need to be at. My GPS tells me all and I get there. It's much easier that way."

During each flight, when sitting at the hold short line and receiving "Cleared for Takeoff" from the tower, both pilots never looked at the approach end for any aircraft approaching nor down the runway to see if it was clear before starting the takeoff roll.

After exiting the Class C Airspace, I said, "Let's contact ATC and use Flight Following." More old school comments. Then each pilot tells me that they solely rely on ForeFlight and ADS-B for separation. I said there is no harm in using both, whereas they said that's more work. I dialed it in anyway and had them ask ATC. Enroute, i noticed both pilots kept their heads in the cockpit looking at pretty colored pictures and ignoring ATC and not looking out the windows. These are VFR flights.

Enroute on one flight, I noticed a Cessna at our 2 o'clock position about 1,000 feet below. I call the aircraft out. The pilot replies without lifting his head, "I don't see it on my screen." At about 1 o'clock ATC calls out the aircraft to us. The pilot still says he doesn't see it on his screen. I said, "GET YOUR F***EN EYES OUT OF THE COCKPIT, LOOK AT OUR 12 TO 1 O'CLOCK POSITION AND TELL ATC YOUR LOOKING FOR THE AIRCRAFT." I watch the Cessna pass under our nose about 600 ft below. I point out the Cessna with my finger outside his left window and he finally sees the Cessna as ATC tells us traffic is no longer a factor. Then he still says, "I never saw it on my screen." A total lack of situational awareness outside the cockpit. A learned behavior from spending majorly of his time with concentrated tunnel vision looking at little colored pictures on electronic screens and totally oblivious of anything outside his field of view.

Wayne
Every year I have to complete a Risk Management course as part of my DoD assignment. In this year's class, we all reviewed an accident that caused life altering injuries to three of the four crew members involved. I'm not allowed to give any specifics on who, what, or where. I can say that two of the crew members were sitting with tunnel vision looking at their phones and lacking any situational awareness when they should have remained as active participants of the crew. Their inattentiveness took away two sets of eyes and cognitive input that definitely would have helped prevent the accident. Their actions increased the level of risk for all involved. All four military members have been trained extensively and taught to remain situationally aware of their surroundings. This was not performed and an accident was the result.

Yes, the OG is blaming the young people involved because of their youth culture that caused life altering injuries. The exact reason why Risk Management courses are required every year in an attempt to break the negative behavior that causes negative outcomes.

Wayne
Exactly Bryan. The reason why the Army is performing a stand down. To review if any deviation from training and/or if any external factors has contributed to the increase of recent accidents and deaths. What Army Aviators do in preparation for and during combat is very dangerous and it is always sad when good lives are lost. Especially when the external and negative actions/behaviors can be definitively recognized and a mitigation plan is implemented for future accident prevention.

The lack of situational awareness by ignoring or blocking out all external awareness of activity around one's own self while intensely focusing on with tunnel vision an object with pretty little colored pictures that has developed into a learned behavior and lifestyle is not the sole answer for all accidents. It is a growing contributing factor in many major accidents within and outside of aviation.

A SoCal Metrolink passenger train collides head on with a Union Pacific freight train because the Metrolink Engineer was texting.


A Welsh Public Service video on the dangers of distracted driving.


Distracted walking


Texting while flying.


Wayne
More and more examples of total lack of situational awareness by ignoring or blocking out all external awareness of activity around one's own self while intensely focusing on with tunnel vision an object with pretty little colored pictures.



Second incident at the same location in Hawaii

 

bryancobb

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2010
Messages
5,321
Location
Cartersville, GA
Aircraft
Owned Brantly B-2b/Fly Kitfox III/Mini-500b
Total Flight Time
1350
Say This More Often!
A few years ago, I delivered a Tomahawk from Atlanta to Pittsburgh. I did not have a GPS. The plane only had one VOR Receiver and one very strong COMM. Used Flight Following 100%. Did it old school. Each controller asked me why I was not on a straight line. Marked route on charts with 5nm red dotted lines each side to note all towers etc. even though I was at 7500ft. I speculate that most WO-1 grads these days would be terrified to attempt this alone.

I have a 20 y/o daughter is a junior at Embry-Riddle in Aerospace Engineering. If you took her phone away, she'd make an F in every class. Foundational skills are non-existent.
 

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
Say This More Often!
A few years ago, I delivered a Tomahawk from Atlanta to Pittsburgh. I did not have a GPS. The plane only had one VOR Receiver and one very strong COMM. Used Flight Following 100%. Did it old school. Each controller asked me why I was not on a straight line. Marked route on charts with 5nm red dotted lines each side to note all towers etc. even though I was at 7500ft. I speculate that most WO-1 grads these days would be terrified to attempt this alone.

I have a 20 y/o daughter is a junior at Embry-Riddle in Aerospace Engineering. If you took her phone away, she'd make an F in every class. Foundational skills are non-existent.
I agree with you Bryan. If this subject is worth saying once, it is worth saying a 1,000 times!

It is sad about your daughter and her generation. Didn't you tell her to completely know and understand the engineering concepts without the electronic crutches?

40+ years ago when I was ferrying Cessnas to the West Coast from the Wichita factory, 90% of those new planes didn't have any NAVCOM radios (owners would have new NAVCOMs installed at their location). Handheld radios such as the Terra TPX 720 were very expensive and the batteries didn't last very long.

tJJ9Q_W_0IAHvD2-2_j0Aa_WQxxPT4X5QLYe45GbOIaNPRgUrtWOy3dKQExYxT6RKhPsyMfSr4JdmlL6D9uKzrLorA_DTAn-tibeI-O-1LFLJs0p8eD4YSCTNw73H-7TpV_IQMnN6WTnE96Ddt9y8po


All navigation for those XC flights were performed by "Pilotage." This was during the days when one had to telephone by landline or visit a FAA Flight Service Station for weather and NOTAM information. Not once did I ever become lost or not know where I was along my route of flight. During these ferry flights, I either flew into uncontrolled airfields, or I would call the airport tower by telephone at my previous stop, say type of aircraft and "N" number, inform them the aircraft has no on board avionics, and gave them my planned ETA. They in turn would tell me where to enter into their airspace, the pattern to land, and watch for the green light. Remember, this was before required transponders with altitude encoding. This worked very well with never a problem or incident.

Here's the update on the FAA program to decommission some of the VORs across CONUS.


Wayne
 

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
I desire to add, during those ferry flights, I would use military Tactical Pilotage Charts (TPC) for navigation since I could obtain those charts for free and I could exchange for new charts when the old expired. I also carried a printed AOPA Airport Guide Book for airport information. As every pilot of my generation and before me, I sat down with a lead pencil, plotter, and aluminum E6B and planned out each leg of the flight with either my sectional and/or TCP. I imprinted within my brain, the situational awareness required to perform such a flight safely. I always knew beforehand my alternates along the route. I continuously exercised my brain figuring my ground speed during each leg with my E6B and my old fashioned analog wrist watch.


BTW, for those who have never viewed TPCs and for those who want to go back in time, here's a nice link of a collection of various TPCs that have been archived on the University of Texas website.


Wayne
 
Last edited:

bryancobb

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2010
Messages
5,321
Location
Cartersville, GA
Aircraft
Owned Brantly B-2b/Fly Kitfox III/Mini-500b
Total Flight Time
1350
I desire to add, during those ferry flights, I would use military Tactical Pilotage Charts (TCP) for navigation since I could obtain those charts for free and I could exchange for new charts when the old expired. I also carried a printed AOPA Airport Guide Book for airport information. As every pilot of my generation and before me, I sat down with a lead pencil, plotter, and aluminum E6B and planned out each leg of the flight with either my sectional and/or TCP. I imprinted within my brain, the situational awareness required to perform such a flight safely. I always knew beforehand my alternates along the route. I continuously exercised my brain figuring my ground speed during each leg with my E6B and my old fashioned analog wrist watch.


BTW, for those who have never viewed TPCs and for those who want to go back in time, here's a nice link of a collection of various TPCs that have been archived on the University of Texas website.


Wayne
Never saw a 500,000. The 1/50,000 Topos were our Ft. Rucker ones.
 

bryancobb

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2010
Messages
5,321
Location
Cartersville, GA
Aircraft
Owned Brantly B-2b/Fly Kitfox III/Mini-500b
Total Flight Time
1350
Didn't you tell her to completely know and understand the engineering concepts without the electronic crutches?
Yea, I tell her every chance I get. Does she care? No. The only kids who show that they do, are the Hindu Indians. The girl has a 3.87 GPA, but she don't have a clue. She's taking Dynamics and Thermo' and Aerodynamics I this semester so let's see how this goes. In reality, every intense design calculation she will ever do on the job will be done using MATLAB software. Design will be done in 3D using CATIA. She does have tremendous common mechanical sense. She changes her own oil and can understand noises a car makes and can tell a mechanic. SHE IS GEN-X'r.
 

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA

rcflier

Experienced Gyroplane Pilot
Joined
May 24, 2007
Messages
667
Location
Nexø (Denmark)
Aircraft
Auto-Gyro MTO Sport 914 (upgraded MT-03)
Total Flight Time
32 as PIC
The past year on two separate occasions, I was invited to fly X-country with two different young (twenty-something year old) pilots. Each flight was months apart. They were building time to obtain their CFI.
What got me was both pilots asked me, "Do you always waste your time doing this planning before every flight? I said, "Yes always since day one when I started to fly. And it is NEVER waited time" Again each reply was almost verbatim. "If I need any of this information, I will do this during the flight there. Otherwise I deal with the changes when it happens. That's what GPS and phones are for." I told them in performing this exercise before every flight, you will lay down the foundation for situational awareness within your brain. They have become familiar with everything before entering the cockpit. Then their reply was, "I don't do this when I get into my car. I don't know the route nor my location I need to be at. My GPS tells me all and I get there. It's much easier that way."

During each flight, when sitting at the hold short line and receiving "Cleared for Takeoff" from the tower, both pilots never looked at the approach end for any aircraft approaching nor down the runway to see if it was clear before starting the takeoff roll.

After exiting the Class C Airspace, I said, "Let's contact ATC and use Flight Following." More old school comments. Then each pilot tells me that they solely rely on ForeFlight and ADS-B for separation.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That's so scary!!! They are on their way to becoming CFI's and they aren't even qualified to be students!!

Who in the darkest Hel* trained them and cleared them ab initio? He/they should be punished severely.

No notams, no weather, no lookout, no radio, no planning at all - "Just do it" as on the T-shirts.

Radio is mandatory in many places like RMZ and CTZ. Haven't they flown there? And not having planned an altenate field is illegal (here)...

And they probably don't care that not every plane may have a working ADS-B (we don't have it here in DK).

I feel relatively safe when I know ATC is looking out for me, as I'm far from infallible.

Erik
 

WaspAir

Supreme Allied Gyro CFI
Joined
Oct 21, 2006
Messages
6,595
Location
Colorado front range
Aircraft
Bell 47G-3B-1, A&S 18A, Phoebus C, SGS 1-26A, etc.
Total Flight Time
rather a lot
My concession to modern tech is that with ADS-B and a 406 MHz ELT with GPS, I don't file vfr flight plans as consistently as I once did. I still always carry paper charts and plan as conscientiously as ever.
 

bryancobb

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2010
Messages
5,321
Location
Cartersville, GA
Aircraft
Owned Brantly B-2b/Fly Kitfox III/Mini-500b
Total Flight Time
1350
I would get the TPCs and ANCs from the Air Guard.

The 1/50,000 Topos are good for finding the proper LZ and for artillery spotting.

This should bring back memories Bryan.


Wayne
Yep. If I remember right, we had to trim the white borders off of 24 of those to make our French maps. They confiscated them when we graduated and burned them so no future WOC could buy them.
 

nishanh

Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2022
Messages
66
Location
Oregon
Even flying in L.A. Metro with a familiar route and all the many various frequencies memorized, I always had at a minimum a navlog with hdg, leg ETE, frequency info and the latest terminal-area chart on my kneeboard. For my commercial practical, the DPE put his finger on the chart and said "Take me here." I wonder how those CFI's would have fared in that instance.
 

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
What got me was both pilots asked me, "Do you always waste your time doing this planning before every flight? I said, "Yes always since day one when I started to fly. And it is NEVER waited time" Again each reply was almost verbatim. "If I need any of this information, I will do this during the flight there. Otherwise I deal with the changes when it happens. That's what GPS and phones are for." I told them in performing this exercise before every flight, you will lay down the foundation for situational awareness within your brain. They have become familiar with everything before entering the cockpit. Then their reply was, "I don't do this when I get into my car. I don't know the route nor my location I need to be at. My GPS tells me all and I get there. It's much easier that way."

During each flight, when sitting at the hold short line and receiving "Cleared for Takeoff" from the tower, both pilots never looked at the approach end for any aircraft approaching nor down the runway to see if it was clear before starting the takeoff roll.

After exiting the Class C Airspace, I said, "Let's contact ATC and use Flight Following." More old school comments. Then each pilot tells me that they solely rely on ForeFlight and ADS-B for separation.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That's so scary!!! They are on their way to becoming CFI's and they aren't even qualified to be students!!

Who in the darkest Hel* trained them and cleared them ab initio? He/they should be punished severely.

No notams, no weather, no lookout, no radio, no planning at all - "Just do it" as on the T-shirts.

Radio is mandatory in many places like RMZ and CTZ. Haven't they flown there? And not having planned an altenate field is illegal (here)...

And they probably don't care that not every plane may have a working ADS-B (we don't have it here in DK).

I feel relatively safe when I know ATC is looking out for me, as I'm far from infallible.

Erik
Yes it is very scary Erik. This developed negative behavior/lifestyle is a direct result of runway incursions, deviations, and accidents within aviation, and in all other modes of transportation.

Wayne
 

rcflier

Experienced Gyroplane Pilot
Joined
May 24, 2007
Messages
667
Location
Nexø (Denmark)
Aircraft
Auto-Gyro MTO Sport 914 (upgraded MT-03)
Total Flight Time
32 as PIC
Wayne, to me it looks like you have the sentence backwards?
 

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
Yes it is very scary Erik. This developed negative behavior/lifestyle is a direct result of runway incursions, deviations, and accidents within aviation, and in all other modes of transportation.

Wayne
You're correct. It is the direct "cause" of...

I find that my brain works faster than my mouth when speaking, or my fingers upon a keyboard. A baud rate disconnect.

Thank you for the correction.

Wayne
 

rcflier

Experienced Gyroplane Pilot
Joined
May 24, 2007
Messages
667
Location
Nexø (Denmark)
Aircraft
Auto-Gyro MTO Sport 914 (upgraded MT-03)
Total Flight Time
32 as PIC
I find that my brain works faster than my mouth when speaking, or my fingers upon a keyboard. A baud rate disconnect.
Strange - I have the opposite disorder... ;-)
 

rancherman

Active Member
Joined
May 30, 2023
Messages
126
Location
Nebraska
I never thought the movie "Idiocracy" was more than a B flick... but dang it, I swear it's a blueprint on how humanity is headed... much faster than the 500 years into the future where the story was set.

Wayne, your 'Burning Man' post from last week and this one share some underlying issues.
 
Last edited:

500e

Active Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2008
Messages
541
Location
UK
Aircraft
500c\d\e 300C & CBi
Total Flight Time
a lot more now
Always scan the Notams have the radio freq on a paper list paper chart with a route / times sketched in, and a thorough walk round first
 

okikuma

Member
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3,278
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
My concession to modern tech is that with ADS-B and a 406 MHz ELT with GPS, I don't file vfr flight plans as consistently as I once did. I still always carry paper charts and plan as conscientiously as ever.
Sometimes when flying a long XC on severe VFR days, I'd file IFR just to remain in practice within that ATC relm. On shorter flights within the busy airspace of SoCal, I use flight following. ADS-B in and out has not diminished my flight following usage. ADS-B is an extra tool. not a replacement tool. While using flight following, I need not to file a VFR flight plan. ATC knows I exist within the airspace. Bedsides, using flight following is perfect for unexpected in flight emergencies since one is already communicating with ATC. During an emergency, I can continue to aviate and navigate while ATC is communicating.

During those ferry flights with aircraft that had no avionics, I always flied a VFR flight plan.

I never thought the movie "Idiocracy" was more than a B flick... but dang it, I swear it's a blueprint on how humanity is headed... much faster than the 500 years into the future where the story was set.

Wayne, your 'Burning Man' post from last week and this one share some underlying issues.
No underlying issue.

Six rules to live by:

1. Aviate, Navigate, Communicate
2. Always leave yourself an "out."
3. Nothing flies without fuel
4. Takeoff is optional
5. Stay out of the clouds - an IFR rating gives the pilot the ability to know when to stay on the ground.
6. Never let an aircraft take you to a location that your brain hasn't arrived 15 min previously.

Very valid rules outside aviation too.

Wayne
 
Top